Soap Opera Discussion Groups and Forums

All My Children Discussion Group

Topic: Parade bone marrow through waiting room? HUH?


Topic Posted by: DingUhLing
Date Posted: Tue Mar 9 19:24:48 2010
Additional Comments:

Did anyone else think it odd that the bone marrow was brought through the waiting room for the family to see????????  I would think hospitals other than PVH would have a more descreet method to transport donations during an operation.  You medical types out there....what's up with that?





Add a MessageGuidelinesTopics ListHomeOther SoapsDaily Recaps for the Show!Registration
Posted by: LuvToLaf
Date posted: Wed Mar 10 20:01:20 2010
Message:
To me, what was more laughable were the onlookers just waiting for JR to suddenly wake up.

Respond to this message


Posted by: jeanne
Date posted: Wed Mar 10 18:33:19 2010
Message:
The whole thing was AMC at it finest, I can not believe that they have no consultants to look these things up and make it at least some what believable. It will save JR and Annie will be mistreated because of it.  JR will find out it was Annie and I am sure he will attack every one for letting her do it.

Respond to this message


Posted by: jinx
Date posted: Tue Mar 9 22:45:22 2010
Message:
I'm so sure the procedure is done in a room in full public view with the whole family looking on. Only in PV.

Replies: (list all replies)

  • That's what I was thinking - since when are these, or any hospital procedures, done in full view of the family??? JR looked like he was in a regular hospital room rather than in an operating room (or wherever this bone marrow transplant should be taking place) right off the hallway so everyone could watch. Made no sense to me, but I don't live in Pine Valley! Not alot in the valley makes sense to me! /Yochell
  • I'm surprised they weren't right there surrounding his bed and getting in the way. /eom - jinx.
  • It seems only Richie knew the correct way to get bone marrow, he had a real ''Doctor'' that did the procedure in a make believe operating room but it looked more professional than this mess. /goldie
  • So true! /eom - jinx

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: mistygrace
    Date posted: Tue Mar 9 20:35:15 2010
    Message:

    That scene looked ridiculous, but reminded me of that ONE TREE HILL Episode , where some guy in his hospital gown, actually waits for his heart to arrive in the waiting room! LOL! And when the heart arrives, the man carrying the heart in some cheap looking foam ice box, accidentally trips, & the heart falls to the floor, & the dog grabs it to eat it! The episode was soo BAD that it was made fun of on E!'s SOUP! LOL!


    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Vivian
    Date posted: Tue Mar 9 20:29:58 2010
    Message:

    Just another silly soap thing they do. 

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • Awe, Vivian, I love your reply. It is so uncomplicated, on the mark and done so very often. Perhaps we should come up with another acronym ,ASST ''Another Silly Soap Thing''. :) eom Suds

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Suds
    Date posted: Tue Mar 9 19:58:05 2010
    Message:
    Ha, I saw that too and thought ''what is that parade all about''?     Perhaps it is an education tool to let us see the many tools that is needed for that transfer.  Yet, I didn't need to see that, nor is the entire audiance brain dead on the complexity with most transplants.  The parade is ''over'' dramatisation at its best.

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: katy kennicott
    Date posted: Tue Mar 9 19:51:50 2010
    Message:
    I have participated in many BMTs. The patients are usually in an isolation unit and can have only family members as visitors - often only one or two. After the marrow is harvested it is sent to the lab for various tests and is labeled and then delivered to the unit where the BMT is to take place. They are correct in that it is delivered via IV to a central line. Then you have to wait for the ''take.'' BMT patients have to have many months of tests to determine if the donor marrow is making blood cells and to make sure that no stray recipient cells are active. It takes many months for the patient to start making a sufficient amount of T cells. I'm sure I'm forgetting something here but I've never seen donor marrow delivered the way it was today. Just sayin' . . .

    Replies: (list all replies)

  • ...interesting, katy -- thanks for giving us your RealLife info! Now, was JR's reaction to the iv transfer realistic? Would a patient have a seizure-like response to bone marrow cells or was that just more *drama*?...buddz
  • I've never seen a seizure. Most of the ones I have worked with are VERY sick and exhausted. They've been undergoing chemo and/or radiation and post bone marrow destruction are really wiped out. He could be having a reaction to the bone marrow transplant . This strikes me as a little overly dramatic. That's not to say that BMTs are not dramatic AND traumatic for the families who have to watch a loved one go through this. Believe me, it's no day in the park. That said, it still tends to be more low key than this has been. Also, they have really diminished the role of the donor. This is a painful procedure not without its own risks. My niece was a donor several years ago and has a large defect on her posterior and had some rather significant pain for several weeks afterward. However, she said she'd do it again, if needed. I have so much respect and honor those who donate marrow - especially for someone they don't know. These are the real heroes in my world. eom/kk
  • ...thanks, kk! Overly dramatic is to be expected but lets hope they get most of it right...buddz
  • I had a friend who was a candidate for a BMT. (Unfortunately, he didn't make it.) However, I do remember that he was going to have to live in a 'clean apartment' near the hospital for several months following the procedure with no one else living or visiting there except his wife (due to possibility of infection.) I have no doubt that JR will be up and out in a week.
  • Oops, forgot to sign above message. Redbird

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: goldie
    Date posted: Tue Mar 9 19:40:03 2010
    Message:
    I thought the bone marrow was transferred with the patients in the same room side by side. Never heard of it being shown to the family like a prised piece of meat. Geeez!

    Respond to this message


    Posted by: Gary
    Date posted: Tue Mar 9 19:39:32 2010
    Message:

    Paraded to an isolation room that the doors do not shut all the way,  can you not sterile????


    Respond to this message


    Add a MessageGuidelinesTopics ListHomeOther SoapsDaily Recaps for the Show!Registration