Topic Posted by: Media
Date Posted: Tue Sep 23 14:20:25 2008
Additional Comments: It seems that when the sneaking around stopped, the fun left the relationship. Holdumb w/b w Lily "only" because she's what's left, now that Carly has dumped him. And, Carly wants what others have. Ah, Jack is dating, now he is looking good again to her..
Posted by: Cooley418 Date posted: Tue Oct 7 11:58:49 2008
Message: I liked them together. The writers just changed their minds and wimped out.
Not my take on it at all. Holden was the player in this deal. After rushing off from Carly to confess to Lily, he remained wishy-washy about what he wanted. Then Carly took all the flap.
She wants Jack now? She has wanted him all along, much to our disappointment. I wish Carly were more fickle, because then she would not have her whole being be about Jack.
